Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Even the Dog Knows What the Doorbell Is

or
A Continuing Argument Against the term “User Generated Content”

Brainerd, Minnesota is about three hours north of Minneapolis. If you haven’t heard of it, you’re not alone and I certainly don’t fault you. It’s a resort town for hunters, fishermen and the occasional motion picture (Fargo was shot here, the locals are mighty proud). I’m not a local and for that I’m equally proud. Today, we’re talking about what’s MINE.

The house I live and work in is a fully restored 100-year-old Sears & Roebucks’ clone. It’s comfy, nice to look at, surprisingly well insulated (WHEW!) but when a previous owner rebuilt it he oddly left out a doorbell. Knock loud little missionaries, I’m working with headphones on, blasting William Shatner’s Has Been directly into my brain (“You’re gonna Diiiie!”).

I have two pets, a cat and a dog. Technically, I have four, but the goldfish don’t inspire me to comm about them… they don’t do much more than look at me longingly for food three seconds after they’ve been fed. My, they are exciting.

Oliver is a one-year-old Jack Russell Terrier, which means genetically he’s one of the smartest breeds of dog. Sadly, Oliver is from the shallow end of the gene pool. Whenever a doorbell rings on TV he goes barking like a fool and runs to the door. I’ve had this dog since he was a pup, I’ve raised him in this house, and he has never heard a doorbell. The previous owner whelped him and raised him for seven-and-a-half-weeks in a barn. Now, that’s a SPECIAL kind of stupid.

But is it really? Perhaps he’s channeling another dog (Patricia Arquette, where have you gone?) or the sound of the doorbell has somehow been hardwired into the psyche of the beast (Pavlov, you BITCH!). It doesn’t matter, the fact remains that the dog knows exactly what a doorbell is for.

You, the blog reading, podcast listening, forum trolling public know what The Comm is by instinct. You might have been introduced to it at one point (few of us were born with a mouse in our hands. No, that’s not a mouse). Using it is easy: pick the format you like, are comfortable with, are forced to use or is company policy and go. The problem, of course, is that you are creating communication on an unprecedented level. Where your ancestors (or, {gasp}, you) once said things, thought things, and believed things that would be communed and vanish into the ether, now they become a permanent part of The Comm - that part of the online world that allows you (YOU!) to be on record as having said something, anything or nothing… kinda makes you fuzzy, doesn’t it? We’re in this together, you know. Our 15-minutes have been stretched to a lifetime… but if everyone is famous why would we care who’s got the time today?

It’s all about the little dog and the doorbell -- we know it’s there, we know it means something, but the house isn’t wired for sound and opening the door is scary. Do you bark at the noise or break out the braided copper and get to work?

Identifying what The Comm is, what we have, what I have is what has brought all this up and why I’m writing today (you lucky dog, you!). The Comm is MINE! It’s not OURS, it’s MINE. You’re equally entitled to say “It’s MINE” and I encourage you to do so, but don’t make the mistake of believing that we SHARE The Comm, we don’t. The Comm is about controlling your own reality and not only how you choose to perceive it but how you choose to RECEIVE it. No one has the same Comm.

All Comms are Equal, but Some Comms are More Equal Than Others.

Comm again?
Kep!

5 comments:

Mark said...

I partially disagree with your last paragraph.
it's also about not only getting *others* to perceive it, but about attempting (in some part) to control how they do so.

There's this false perception of anonymity online. People think as long as they don't do certain things (like add email links, or post the url publically) they think they're not 'part of the crowd'. and even though they only control the source, they still attempt to maintain control about how it's perceived. Just in the way they present it, or where they promote it

Think about it: The media has been biased for years, about everything. And the "court of public opinion" is the result of that. Now, people are STILL trying to bias outside observers, but the variables, the tangibles, the... broadcast (if you will) is on a whole other level

The fact is, people WANT sympathy, and will attempt to garner it anyway they can. How many times have you read one sided accounts online? Yet, the person who wrote the account could be 10 times bitchier than the person they're complaining about. What I'm talking about is, traditional "content presentation" in a new medium. One that doesn't quite conform to the old ways of doing things

Jim "Kep!" Keplinger said...

And thus, we come back to being the dog and the doorbell. So many people are barking because they just know there is something out there, and they want to be the first to see it, but damn few have thumbs enough to open the door.

In the case of Comming, the collective pool of communication now allows us to select the fact's point of origin itself. This is the reason for needing a name, a word, a buzz for UGC... because the user now enters a relationship with the information itself in order to form their own reality... a reality every bit as valid and true as any other. Despite having no experience with a doorbell, the dog's barking. The realities are being formed. The Comm is here.

LDahl said...

I've added your link to my blog.
Comm down:)))

Mark said...

I beg to differ. The realities are not being formed by the relationship between the user and the information. It's the reality that creates the relationship. You can't put the cart before the horse. I don't think things are "jumping ahead" the way you do, for a very simple reason: Change takes time. People don't adapt quickly enough to accept a drastic and sudden change in the status quo, yet, "Comming" as you put it (I still don't like that word ;Þ), has spread like wildfire. Why? Because it's still the "familiar", only now it has a different colored light shining upon it.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://dcxvssh.com]qQiGyXcCpESEnGLYO[/url] , OkBHTobvvJHXxDSC - http://yuxeflk.com